They handed on a handshake initially, and from there, Biden and Trump went proper to mixing it up on coverage — and one another — in their first 2024 presidential debate on Thursday evening.

Biden arrived with a raspy voice and spoke softly, the outcome, his marketing campaign mentioned, of a chilly. Biden generally mumbled, acquired tongue-tied or misplaced his prepare of thought, a efficiency unlikely to calm anxiousness amongst Democrats and lots of Americans concerning the 81-year-old president.

The 78-year-old Trump, as he typically does, spoke with pressure however with plentiful falsehoods.

▶ Here are another key moments from their 90-minute debate

President Biden and former President Trump traded barbs and quite a lot of false and deceptive info as they confronted off of their first debate of the 2024 election.

Trump falsely represented the Jan. 6 assault on the U.S. Capitol as a comparatively small quantity of people that had been ushered in by police and misstated the energy of the financial system throughout his administration.

Biden, who tends to lean extra on exaggerations and elaborations relatively than outright lies, misrepresented the price of insulin and overstated what Trump mentioned about utilizing disinfectants to handle COVID.

▶ Here’s a take a look at the false and deceptive claims by the 2 candidates

▶ Read extra about how America watched the talk.

The Biden marketing campaign is insisting that the president “started slow but finished strong” because it tries to say victory within the debate.

In a memo, Biden advisers argued that the Trump’s efficiency reminded unbiased voters “why they dislike him,” whereas suggesting that Biden improved because the evening wore on.

Vice President Kamala Harris made related recommendations in TV appearances after the talk.

Biden’s voice was significantly raspy within the debate’s early going, and he repeatedly cleared his throat all through the evening. But the president was additionally onerous to know in his closing assertion, undermining recommendations that he made a lot enchancment.

Trump’s supporters, against this, had been giddy, arguing that Biden seemed befuddled and confused and that their candidate was the clear winner.

Former Republican presidential candidate Nikki Haley is weighing in on Biden’s debate efficiency, repeating her marketing campaign path line that the Democratic president gained’t in the end be his occasion’s 2024 nominee.

Trump’s ultimate competitor within the Republican main, who dropped out in March, mentioned on X after the talk, “Mark my words….Biden will not be the Democrat nominee.”

Haley repeatedly mentioned throughout her personal presidential marketing campaign that Biden wouldn’t find yourself representing his occasion on this yr’s election, making critiques of the president’s age and her perceptions of his stumbles in workplace.

Thursday’s presidential debate was a rerun that featured two candidates with a mixed age of 159, nevertheless it went particularly poorly for one in every of them, President Joe Biden.

The debate coated a variety of matters and included a former president — Trump — not backing down from his vows to prosecute members of Congress and even the person he was debating. But the overarching theme was the distinction between the candidates’ efficiency.

▶ Here are some takeaways from the presidential face-off

While selecting up his order, he mentioned of his efficiency: “I think we did well.” Biden additionally mentioned of his opponent, “It’s hard to debate a liar.”

His voice was raspy and he mentioned he had a sore throat.

Florida Sen. Marco Rubio, a possible Trump vice presidential decide, says he doesn’t know but whom Trump will decide to hitch him on the Republican ticket.

“I don’t know the answer to that and no one’s told me that I am,” he mentioned on CNN after the talk from the spin room. “But we’ll know who it is at some point during the next two weeks.”

Rubio mentioned that he thinks there are eight or 9 individuals who may do a great job within the function and that, “It really comes down to who the president thinks would do a good job.”

“That’s his decision to make,” he says.

Biden, and his spouse, Jill, are on the best way to a Waffle House restaurant to choose up meals for the aircraft earlier than they fly to Raleigh, North Carolina, for a postdebate rally later Friday, the White House says.

Vice President Harris in an interview with MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow once more acknowledges it was a gradual begin, “but I thought it was a strong finish.”

“What we had in Joe Biden is someone who wanted to have a debate based on facts, based on truths, and in Donald Trump, we have what we’ve come to expect, which is someone who is going to push lies and distract from the reality of the damage he has created and continues to create in our country,” Harris mentioned.

In an interview on MSNBC after the talk, California Gov. Gavin Newsom mentioned “there shouldn’t be” panic in his occasion.

“I think it’s unhelpful. And I think it’s unnecessary. We’ve got to go in, we’ve got to keep our heads high. And as I say, we’ve got to have the back of this president. You don’t turn back because of one performance,” Newsom mentioned. “What kind of party does that?”

He continued defending Biden, saying, “This president has delivered. We need to deliver for him.”

More than 50 minutes after he arrived at his watch occasion, Joe Biden lastly departed close to midnight to whoops from an emptying lodge ballroom.

Biden shook fingers and took photos with many supporters alongside a rope line.

President Joe Biden remains to be working the gang of supporters on the lodge in Atlanta. He spoke briefly after the talk and has been chatting with folks for greater than 40 minutes.

Biden has one other packed day on Friday.

After he leaves Atlanta, Biden will contact down in Raleigh, North Carolina, to be in place for a post-debate marketing campaign rally on Friday afternoon.

After that, he’ll head to New York and New Jersey for marketing campaign fundraisers on Friday and Saturday.

Trump co-campaign chief Chris LaCivita referred to as the talk “added rocket fuel” for Trump’s upcoming go to to Virginia. A state Trump has misplaced twice, LaCivita mentioned it’s now in play.

He mentioned he thinks Minnesota, one other state Trump has misplaced twice, may be in play. “We’re on offense, make no mistake about it,” LaCivita mentioned.

LaCivita dismissed chatter about whether or not Democrats would attempt to nominate somebody apart from Biden. “There’s so many political experts on X, so we’ll hear a lot from them, I’m sure, in the next few days because they’ve all run so many campaigns,” LaCivita mentioned sarcastically.

“But the only way that happens is if Joe Biden voluntarily steps down, and he’s not going to do that.”

Jake Tapper and Dana Bash requested questions and never far more, as the 2 candidates basically carried the present on their very own.

Rarely did the moderators leap in and lower off or problem an announcement from Trump or Biden, and the candidates solely fleetingly interacted straight with Bash and Tapper apart from listening to (and solely generally answering) their questions.

It was a stark distinction from debates in earlier presidential election years when different candidates — significantly Trump — jostled at instances with moderators.

For 90 minutes, Trump and Biden had been largely left to do their factor.

Harris appeared irritated by the give attention to Biden’s efficiency, telling CNN’s Anderson Cooper: “I got that this is the after play for the debate, this conversation that I’m in, and I understand why everyone wants to talk about it.”

“But I think it’s also important to recognize that the choice in November between these two people that were on the debate stage involved extraordinary stakes. And there’s one person on that stage who has the endorsement of their vice president, and that’s Joe Biden. Mike Pence is nowhere to be found.”

Wondering how the second debate would possibly differ from tonight’s? You’re going to have to attend awhile.

Biden and Trump’s second debate is scheduled for Sept. 10 on ABC. The community hasn’t but launched particulars on the format.

Thursday’s faceoff was the earliest common election presidential debate ever. The second one can be early, and shall be held greater than six weeks earlier than Election Day.

Trump and Biden used problems with race, immigration and crime to commerce private barbs that always distorted details and sidestepped points central to the issues of many Black and Hispanic voters.

“As Black Americans face some of the most challenging obstacles of our time, we need candidates who are less focused on attacking each other and more focused on attacking the issues,” mentioned Derrick Johnson, president and CEO of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.

“There have been some comments here from Donald Trump that our members here have rejected outright,” mentioned Juan Proaño, president of the League of United Latin American Citizens.

Shortly earlier than the talk, Biden began promoting cans of water labeled, “Dark Brandon’s Secret Sauce,” on his marketing campaign web site, mocking the recommendations from Trump and his advisors within the days main as much as the talk that Biden would seem firey and maybe even use medicine to reinforce his efficiency.

“The secret to a good debate performance? Staying hydrated,” Biden’s marketing campaign web site nonetheless learn after the talk.

Vice President Kamala Harris is weighing in on the presidential debate.

“Listen, first of all, what we saw tonight is the president making a very clear contrast with Donald Trump on all the issues that matter to the American people,” she mentioned.

“Yes there was a slow start but it was a strong finish.”

Asked if she’s involved in wake of Biden’s debate efficiency, she repeated: “It was a slow start. That’s obvious to everyone.

“I’m not going to debate that point. I’m talking about the choice in November. I’m talking about one of the most important elections in our collective lifetime.”

Trump’s aides erupted into loud applause and cheers after he stepped off the talk stage, based on a video shared by an aide.

“President Trump emerges from the stage victorious,” political director James Blair wrote on X, the platform previously referred to as Twitter.

Trump’s aides are extraordinarily comfortable concerning the former president’s efficiency Thursday evening.

Chris LaCivita, Trump’s senior adviser, referred to as it “the most lopsided win in debate history” and mocked the Biden marketing campaign for saying the president had a chilly. “I loved it, right? Classic.”

The debate didn’t precisely make clear the essential problem, despite the fact that Biden has put his assist for baby care on the forefront of his marketing campaign.

When Trump was requested how he would decrease the price of baby care, he ignored the query and went again to defending his resolution to fireplace John Kelly as his chief of workers, who confirmed that Trump had made disparaging remarks about navy veterans. He was given one other probability to reply the query and as an alternative pivoted to speaking about Biden’s ballot numbers.

Biden, in jumbled remarks, talked about baby care in ways in which had been at instances tough to comply with, even because the White House tries to make the case that Biden’s file investments in baby care introduced ladies again to the workforce.

When he was requested what he needed to say to Black voters who had been “disappointed he hadn’t made more progress” on closing racial disparities, he mentioned, “We got to make sure we provide for child care costs … because when you provide those child care protections, you create economic growth because more people can be in the job market.”

Biden mentioned his opponent has “done virtually nothing” on baby care. “We should significantly increase the child care tax credit. We should significantly increase the availability of women and men, er, single parents to be able to go back to work.”

You can rewatch the complete CNN presidential debate utilizing the livestream beneath.

Biden informed supporters in his temporary look after the talk: “Look we’re going to beat this guy. We need to beat this guy and I need you in order to beat him.”

“God love you all,” he mentioned earlier than stepping off the stage to greet a few of these supporters.

Biden continued to work the gang at his watch occasion in downtown Atlanta for greater than quarter-hour after making a short assertion.

All of Biden’s high surrogates marched into the spin room en masse, creating an enormous media scrum. One by one, all of them gave their takes on Biden’s efficiency earlier than entertaining shouted questions from the handfuls of reporters gathered round them.

• California Governor Gavin Newsom informed reporters that he was happy with Biden. “Tonight I think Joe Biden not only asserted himself, he reminded people of his accomplishments and his vision for the future.”
• Donald Trump’s niece, Mary Trump, informed reporters that her uncle has “one policy position — to keep himself out of prison.” She referred to as him a traitor to his nation and famous that “the people who know him best can’t support him.”
• Democratic Rep. Robert Garcia of California referred to as the talk “a clear contrast between a good man that we believe in that is going to win reelection and a con man, a criminal and a traitor to this country.”

At his watch occasion, Biden is attempting to give attention to Trump’s falsehoods.

“I can’t think of one thing he said that is true,” the president informed supporters.

“Tonight, President Biden presented a positive and winning vision for the future of America,” marketing campaign chair Jen O’Malley Dillon wrote, including, “On the other side of the stage was Donald Trump, who offered a dark and backwards window into what America will look like if he steps foot back in the White House.”

President Joe Biden addressed a room stuffed with supporters following the talk on Thursday.

Thanking them for his or her assist, he mentioned: “Let’s keep going. See you at the next one.”

On Biden’s efficiency and any speak of Democrats turning to a different nominee, Miller mentioned a transfer can be “structurally impossible.”

“Sorry, Democrats. You have your nominee,” Miller mentioned.

Democrats are panicking and need casting over what may have been following Biden’s uneven debate efficiency. But David Axelrod, the Democratic strategist who helped propel Barack Obama’s meteoric rise, says the one one who may exchange Joe Biden because the occasion’s nominee is Joe Biden himself.

“He is the nominee of the Democratic Party. This isn’t the ‘60s,” Axelrod said. “Only he can decide.”

“This is a guy with a lot of pride who believes in himself” and probably thinks he had just one bad night,” Axelrod continued. The problem is “it’s one evening that helped affirm peoples’ fears.”

Biden has returned to the lodge the place he spent a lot of the day to talk to supporters who’re partying after they watched the published of the talk.

Music is taking part in and individuals are dancing in a convention room adorned with Biden-Harris indicators and pictures of Biden’s trademark aviator sun shades.

Standing alone on a stage in Los Angeles, Kennedy opened his occasion, dubbed The Real Debate, by accusing CNN, host of the principle contest, of colluding with the Republican and Democratic events to maintain him off.

“This is something that’s important for our democracy because Americans feel like the system is rigged,” Kennedy mentioned throughout his opening remarks. “This is exactly the kind of merger of state and corporate power that I’m running to oppose.”

Aside from the livestreamed response to the talk, Kennedy has nothing on his public schedule for the approaching weeks. Nor does his working mate, philanthropist Nicole Shanahan.

Georgia state Rep. Billy Mitchell, a number one Democrat within the suburban Atlanta Democratic heartland of DeKalb County, mentioned he thought Biden may overcome the efficiency.

“The bar was set so low by his opponent that he certainly exceeded that,” Mitchell mentioned mentioned on the Biden marketing campaign watch occasion in downtown Atlanta. “The reality is we love Joe Biden because of where his heart is, despite if he looked like he had a cold here and there.”

Former Democratic presidential candidate Julian Castro mentioned in a submit on X that, “Biden had a very low bar going into the debate and failed to clear even that bar. He seemed unprepared, lost, and not strong enough to parry effectively with Trump, who lies constantly.”

Trump is on his method again to his personal aircraft as his aides and supporters gloat about his efficiency Thursday evening.

He’s not planning to cease by the spin room, leaving that job to surrogates, which embody a number of of his vice presidential short-listers.

As the talk got here to a detailed, Trump supporter retired police officer Nick Glaub, of Ross, Ohio, watched along with his ft kicked up onto a close-by efficiency stage, a can of Corona sitting on the desk.

Glaub was happy with Trump’s debate efficiency and mentioned he seen the dearth of assault strains from Trump. “I just think he held his composure,” he mentioned.

Chuck Thompson, a Trump supporter from Mason, Ohio, who got here to the watch occasion decked in an American flag button-down shirt, was additionally pleased with Trump’s debate efficiency, noting the distinction in tone from Trump’s final debate towards President Biden in 2020.

“He’s learned how to control his temper,” he mentioned.

Ramaswamy says Trump “hands down” gained the last decade and will have even swayed unbiased voters.

The former GOP hopeful says Trump confirmed extra power than Biden, whom he portrayed as susceptible and unable doubtlessly to complete his time period, not to mention win one other.

Ramaswamy characterised Biden‘s ongoing presidency as a possible risk to nationwide safety for what he argued was displaying weak spot.

Trump and Biden bickered over how far they will hit a golf ball and their stamina on the course, with Trump bragging about trophies he’s gained and Biden claiming he’s been a single-digit handicap.

Trump famous he just lately gained two championships at a golf course he owns. He then bashed Biden, claiming with out proof that the president can’t hit the ball 50 yards. Biden responded that, as vice chairman, he had a relatively aggressive six handicap — and once more challenged Trump to a golf match, however provided that his foe carried his bag of golf equipment himself.

“Think you can do it?” requested Biden, whose handicap is listed on the United States Golf Association’s web site as 6.7, with the final replace in July 2018. Trump’s handicap final up to date in June 2021 is listed as 2.5.

Trump then sought to close down the golf dialogue. “Let’s not act like children,” Trump mentioned.

“You are a child,” Biden retorted.

In golf, a handicap is a measure of a participant’s ability. The decrease the handicap, the higher the participant is.

Fifteen minutes after the talk ended, there have been solely Republicans speaking to the press within the spin room.

There had been at the very least seven high-profile Republican officers within the room, together with Stefanik, Donalds, Ramaswamy and Whatey.

There had been no Democrats.

Trump walked straight off the stage alone after the talk.

Biden was joined by his spouse Jill, who watched from a inexperienced room. They hugged and kissed and he or she held his hand and appeared to help him down the steps as they approached Bash and Tapper to greet the moderators earlier than leaving.

President Joe Biden has lastly discovered some traction on a difficulty that has dogged a lot of his presidency – immigration – however he largely averted it as Trump repeatedly hammered him with unsubstantiated claims that folks had been coming throughout the border from prisons and psychological well being establishments.

In his closing remarks, Biden mentioned taxes, child-care credit, lead pipes and inflation however nothing about his current measures on immigration. On Wednesday, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas mentioned arrests for unlawful border crossings plunged greater than 40% since asylum processing was halted June 5.

The asylum halt infuriated some in his Democratic base, however Biden thrilled them two weeks later by saying he would ease the trail to authorized standing for an estimated 500,000 spouses of U.S. residents.

Trump, as anticipated, turned to a signature problem in his closing remarks, blaming Biden for “allowing millions and millions of people to pour in.”

Biden has departed the talk corridor.

Biden started his closing assertion with a voice that was even scratchier than earlier and was at instances onerous to know. He mentioned of his administration, “We’ve made significant progress from the debacle that was left by President Trump in his last term.”

Biden mentioned Trump cuddled as much as North Korean chief Kim Jong Un and Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Trump has a protracted historical past of admiring feedback about Putin, together with calling Putin’s ways within the 2022 invasion of Ukraine “genius” and “very savvy.”

Trump met with North Korean chief Kim Jong Un thrice throughout his presidency and had referred to as Kim “a pretty smart cookie.” In 2018, throughout a short thaw, Trump mentioned he and Kim exchanged letters and that “we fell in love.”

“He wrote me beautiful letters and they are great letters,” Trump mentioned.

Trump says Kim, Putin and President Xi Jinping of China “don’t respect him” and “don’t fear him.”

Abortion is without doubt one of the most essential points for Democrats on this yr’s election. The president mischaracterized Roe v. Wade, the landmark Supreme Court ruling that legalized abortion.

When requested if he helps some restrictions on abortion Biden mentioned he, “supports Roe v. Wade, which had three trimesters. The first time is between a woman and a doctor. Second time is between a doctor and an extreme situation. A third time is between the doctor, I mean, between the women and the state.”

He added that he thought medical doctors, not politicians, ought to make choices about “women’s health.”

“We’re living in hell,” Trump mentioned concerning the state of the nation in his closing remarks. “You talk about Charlottesville, this is 100 times, Charlottesville a thousand times the whole country is exploding because of you, because they don’t respect you,” Trump mentioned to Biden, equating the state of the nation with the neo-Nazi rally and counterprotests that shocked the nation initially of Trump’s time period.

After the talk, Biden was greeted on stage by his spouse, Jill. Trump walked off alone.

That’s a wrap on the primary presidential debate.