Here’s a pattern of a number of the on-line feedback we’ve acquired when individuals be taught Brent and I are digital nomads. We’ve lived for months at a time in Hungary, Bulgaria, Turkey, and the Republic of Georgia — all nations that deal with their LGBTQ+ residents both pretty badly or very badly.
Hey guys, what’s it like residing in such homophobic nations?
Aren’t you afraid?
Don’t you understand how Georgia treats queer individuals?
In case you haven’t heard, Hungary simply handed a really anti-LGBTQ+ legislation! How are you able to assist that authorities?
Pack your luggage, we’re happening an journey
Subscribe to our weekly publication for the perfect LGBTQ+ travel guides, tales, and extra.
We’re a homosexual couple, so it’s pure to surprise our opinions on all this.
First, we expect travel to homophobic nations is an advanced subject with no simple solutions. We’ve thought a lot about it.
What are our conclusions? Let’s handle the above questions separately.
What’s it like residing in a homophobic nation like Georgia, Hungary, or Bulgaria?
Whenever we’re requested this query, it’s virtually all the time by a fellow Westerner who could be fascinated with visiting the nation in query.
It’s a good query, and we used to ask, too. But now we all know the query ought to have two components: What’s the nation like for LGBTQ+ guests, particularly typically wealthier Westerners? And what’s it like for the LGBTQ+ individuals who don’t have any selection however to stay there?
Because the 2 solutions are sometimes fairly totally different.
In answering the primary query, Brent and I’ve coined a phrase: The Weird Foreigner Rule.
This implies that while you stay in a rustic aside from your personal, the locals will typically contemplate you an outsider—or, as we put it, “a weird foreigner.” The extra culturally totally different you appear, the weirder locals could contemplate you.
For occasion, once we lived in Tbilisi, Georgia, our light-skinned complexions, baseball caps, and lack of beards clearly marked us as Americans.
Having locals stare at you such as you’ve obtained your nostril the place your chin must be isn’t all the time enjoyable.
Related:
On the opposite hand, the Weird Foreigner Rule has one apparent benefit, particularly for LGBTQ+ vacationers: Since you might be so clearly a bizarre outsider, a lot of the native mores and customs aren’t essentially utilized to you.
You’re already so “weird” that the homosexual factor will get misplaced in every little thing else. Or it will be simply one other instance of overseas “weirdness.”
You’re two middle-aged males sharing an house with just one mattress? You’re Americans, and Americans don’t make a lot sense anyway.
You’re two older girls having a romantic dinner in my restaurant? Great, I would like the enterprise!
Both examples spotlight one other issue concerned within the Weird Foreigner Rule: We’re spending cash that’s typically a vital a part of the native economic system. Therefore, there’s a large financial incentive not to care if somebody is LGBTQ+.
The Weird Foreigner Rule isn’t absolute, and there are different issues to contemplate.
For starters, you’ll be able to solely stray so removed from cultural norms. Sure, your common Turk could not care that two middle-aged American males live subsequent door — even a standard Muslim could not care.
But in the event you stood out within the hallway snogging one another in entrance of their children? Then, they very effectively may care.
The extra you mix in with locals, the better life will most likely be.
And second, the extra you conform to the gender norms of that nation, the better your life will probably be. If you’re an clearly effeminate man, masculine lady, or distinctively non-binary — or refuse to declare a particular gender — you’re extra doubtless to draw undesirable consideration to your self. Gender continues to be an enormous deal in America, however it’s a a lot, a lot larger deal in additional conventional nations. Some cultures are organized and segregated virtually fully by gender.
To be clear, we’re not saying any of that’s truthful or proper. It’s 100% not. But in the event you travel to a much less tolerant or extra conventional nation, you want to pay attention to these points simply in your security.
What is the reply to the second a part of that query? What is life like for native LGBTQ+ of us? Keep in thoughts this isn’t our lived expertise.
But we’ve additionally made many LGBTQ+ pals everywhere in the world and heard many first-hand tales.
In nations similar to Thailand or Vietnam (and lots of Asian nations), there’s a type of benign neglect: there aren’t any legal guidelines towards being homosexual, however no protections both, and sometimes delicate social disapproval. Thailand is pretty supportive of transgender girls (however solely to some extent).
In many Muslim nations, homophobia is rather more overt, with particular, oppressive legal guidelines. Turkey doesn’t permit LGBTQ+ advocacy teams to collect in public, whereas in Georgia, transgender girls face excessive charges of discrimination, abuse, and homicide.
In Istanbul, we met a closeted Turkish man who stated being homosexual was no large deal so long as you acted historically masculine. But on the identical time, he complained concerning the intense stress from his Muslim household to marry a lady.
There aren’t many LGBTQ protections in most Muslim nations.
We hear issues like this rather a lot from LGBTQ+ pals in homophobic nations. Everyone appears to acknowledge issues are dangerous for many who violate gender norms, however life isn’t dangerous for others so long as you’re “discreet” and don’t “flaunt your lifestyle.”
As Westerners, this generally sounds to us like they’re excusing homophobia as a result of having to be “discreet” strikes us as one other type of discrimination.
But we additionally assume it’s not our place to decide individuals residing such wildly totally different life experiences in such troublesome and doubtlessly harmful circumstances.
Which brings us to…
Aren’t you afraid?
No, we’re not often afraid. And that is, largely, due to the Weird Foreigner Rule.
For starters, we each current as conventionally masculine. Except for being two middle-aged males having dinner collectively, or sharing an house, there isn’t a lot to recommend we’re homosexual. We’re not pleased with this; it’s only a assertion of reality.
We additionally aren’t afraid as a result of we do our due diligence forward of time. We discuss to individuals — guests and locals alike. We do a number of analysis. We attempt arduous to ensure we perceive native legal guidelines and mores — which might fluctuate a lot within the totally different cities of a rustic, and even in numerous neighborhoods.
In extra conventional nations, we might by no means behave just like the Travelling Butts — the homosexual Instagram couple whose shtick was to drop trou in entrance of well-known worldwide landmarks. Their antics obtained them arrested in Thailand for public indecency. And frankly? We assume they’re jackasses for thus casually dismissing the mores within the cultures they go to.
We all the time attempt to act like visitors in different nations as a result of we’re! Sometimes, these nations’ values differ significantly from our personal, however we nonetheless attempt to respect them — inside motive.
That being stated, we’d be mendacity if we stated residing in homophobic nations by no means provides us pause.
For occasion, if one thing have been to occur to us — a gay-bashing or simply an old style mugging — would native authorities deal with us otherwise as a result of we’re homosexual? Might they take the aspect the aspect of the gay-bashers over us?
It’s a sobering thought.
Honestly although, we fear much less about our private security than we do once we’re again in America — the land of mass shootings, omnipresent handguns, and having to spend a lot of your life on highways in a automobile.
Don’t you understand how homophobic nations deal with queer individuals?
We do know.
We most likely have a significantly better sense of issues than the particular person asking this query, since we now have many, many LGBTQ+ pals in these totally different nations, and we additionally know a number of queer activists.
Italy is a rustic that’s mildly homophobic, particularly outdoors of the massive cities. Southern Italy, which is extra conventional than the north, is extra homophobic nonetheless.
While residing in Matera in southern Italy, Brent and I gave a presentation to Ris Volta, the world’s first LGBTQ+ group. We talked about our lives as activists and writers and in addition as a longtime couple.
And they informed us their tales, too, about how arduous it is popping out to pals and households, how few out LGBTQ+ of us there have been within the space, and the way very troublesome it was to date or keep a relationship with no public assist.
In Georgia, we grew to become pals with Giorgi Tabagari, the founding father of Tbilisi Pride and the nation’s main LGBTQ+ group. Currently, he’s below investigation by the federal government for swearing at a police officer who was doing nothing about homophobes bodily attacking Tabagari and the workplaces of Tbilisi Pride.
Everywhere we go, we make some extent to meet individuals like this — and pay attention. We provide assist.
At the chance of sounding like White Saviors, we then share what we’ve heard with individuals outdoors that nation. We tweet and write articles concerning the points, and we’ve even held a stay chat with the locals concerned.
That’s additionally a part of the rationale we’ve written this text.
In case you haven’t heard, Hungary simply handed a really anti-LGBTQ legislation! How are you able to assist that authorities?
Again, we all know. Not to sound defensive, however we most likely know extra about it than most. And for the document, we don’t assist Hungary’s authorities, nor these of any homophobic nation.
Look, right here’s the deal: all of us want to resolve how we stay our lives in accordance to our personal private ethics. If you assume it’s flawed to go to homophobic nations — and assist homophobic governments even not directly in any manner — then don’t go to them.
But we truthfully assume the difficulty is extra sophisticated than many individuals make it sound. We’re not towards boycotts generally, however we expect they solely actually work once they’re organized — and when the organizers make particular calls for of their governments.
In different phrases, we expect imprecise, casual boycotts normally solely reach making the boycotter really feel good.
We’ve requested a variety of native LGBTQ+ individuals what they consider boycotts of their homophobic nations. Ineach single case, native individuals have informed us they assume casual boycotts are a horrible concept.
Local LGBTQ+ individuals virtually all the time need extra supportive guests to come to their nations — to assist LGBTQ+ companies, to improve visibility, and to say to homophobic governments: “Look, LGBTQ+ people are nothing to be afraid of, and we need to move into the modern world!”
And no nation is any “one” factor.
We assume going to Budapest as an out homosexual couple is rather more highly effective than merely staying away.
Budapest is much extra liberal and queer-supportive than different components of Hungary (although it’s nonetheless not as progressive as essentially the most liberal American cities). So we expect it’s a good factor to go there and be out and supportive of each the LGBTQ+ group and their straight allies.
We additionally assume it’s good to be as seen as doable in smaller cities and cities, like Keszthely, Hungary, the place we spent six weeks. In locations similar to these, issues are even more durable for the native LGBTQ+ of us.
What actually works to truly make homophobic nations higher for LGBTQ+ individuals? International stress. But for that to work, individuals outdoors the nation want to know what’s happening inside.
And once more, not to sound all White Savior-y, however we expect that’s one thing we can assist with.
There are undoubtedly some locations, like Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Russia, that we’d most likely by no means go to — though now we have pals from a few of these locations too, and even there, the difficulty will be sophisticated.
In the homophobic locations we go to, once we do our due diligence, we don’t really feel unsafe.
When we pay attention to the locals and share what we’ve heard, we really feel like we’re making the world a higher place for LGBTQ+ individuals, not a worse one.
Again, everybody should resolve these points for themselves, and do what feels proper for them.
But we’re very snug with our selections, and we hope extra individuals will make related ones.
Visit these nations, however do it mindfully. Become conscious of LGBTQ+ individuals and points, and assist unfold the phrase about them.
More speaking and listening is nearly all the time higher than much less. We say: Let’s preserve the dialog going.
Brent Hartinger and Michael Jensen, are a homosexual “digital nomad” couple — two males who travel the world repeatedly, residing in numerous nations for wherever from one to three months at a time. Subscribe to their publication at BrentAndMichaelAreGoingPlaces.com.
Want to assist advance LGBTQ+ equality in different nations? Here are some worthwhile teams doing nice work that would use your assist.
